Sunscreen in the Environment
The History of Sunscreen's Effect on Corals
Today, department store shelves are lined with an array of seemingly unlimited sunscreen products with a comparable list of active ingredients. Despite today’s choices, sunscreen lotion has humble beginnings. As far back as 300,000 years ago in Sub-Saharan Africa, people sought ways to protect their skin from the sun using topical pastes made from clays found in the environment. Then with the discovery that ultraviolet radiation (UV) was to blame for skin blisters, scientists in the late 1800s began actively searching for new compounds that would be superior to the salves made by early civilizations.
But modern sunscreens didn’t become popular until the 1980s, once the lotions and creams became appealing enough both in texture, smell, and appearance. Much of this is thanks to oxybenzone, an odorless, colorless chemical with broad spectrum protection. Due to the slow uptake from the general population, it wasn’t until 100 years after the invention of the first laboratory-based sunscreen that people began to realize the implications of sunscreen use on the environment, specifically in the tourist filled oceans near tropical reefs. It is estimated that roughly 14,000 tons of sunscreen enters waterways across the globe every year from both sunscreen applications and wastewater runoff. Coral reefs are particularly susceptible to the active ingredients in commercial sunscreens, with preliminary research indicating the chemicals can stress corals and in high doses cause bleaching. Many countries now ban the use of the most damaging ingredients like oxybenzone and octinoxate.
Gaining perspective on how we got to where we are today requires a look back in time to the events and discoveries of the past. Here is a timeline outlining the use of sunscreen, from its early use thousands of years ago to the creation of “reef safe” formulas that are an attempt to be better for the environment.
Banner Photo Credit: wikivoyage via Wikipedia
Middle Paleolithic use of ochre in Africa
Use of ochre in Sub-Saharan African societies is first documented. Today societies like the Xhosa people in South Africa and the Himba and Ovahimba people in Namibia continue to use ochre as protection against the sun.
Native Americans use pine and flowers
Native Americans use sunflower oil, wallflowers, or pine needles. The Makah and Hesquiat use pine needles from the western hemlock, the Haisla, Hanaksiala, and Kwakiutl use black cottonwood, and the Cahuilla use the pinyon tree. The Zuni ground up the western wallflower plant and northeast tribes use sunflower oil.
First commercial sunscreen sold in the United States
Academics often refer to the “first commercial chemical sunscreen” that appeared on the market in 1928 in the United States. It was an emulsion containing benzyl salicylate and benzyl cinnamate. Very little else is known about this first sunscreen.
US Army begins sunscreen research
The Army Air Force asks the American Medical Association Council of Pharmacy and Chemistry to start a “top secret experiment” studying substances to prevent sun burns. They find dark red veterinary petroleum (aka “red vet pet”) is the best paste for protection. This paste is soon dispatched in military survival kits supplied to soldiers in combat, however it is both thick and smells bad.
Discovery of oxybenzone as sunscreen
Oxybenzone is first discovered to have sun absorbing properties by manufacturing company General Aniline & Film (GAF) Corp. Later we will come to find that oxybenzone is one of the most environmentally toxic active ingredients in commercially produced sunscreens.
The US Food and Drug Administration begins regulating sunscreens
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) begins regulating sunscreens with a focus on UVB protection. They adopt the UVB measure SPF as an appropriate indicator for sunscreen effectiveness. Fourteen UV filters are initially approved, including oxybenzone.
Zinc Oxide becomes popular
Sunscreen brand Zinka popularizes zinc oxide based sunscreens. The white sheen is initially marketed as a cool look, though only a small market adopts the craze with the majority preferring clear lotions with other active ingredients. It is especially popular with surfers. The FDA does not initially classify zinc oxide as an active ingredient in sunscreen and allows for the production of Zinka.
PABA becomes controversial
A study shows exposure to para-aminobenzoic acid causes damage to human DNA. It also becomes apparent that it can cause allergic reactions which leads to its removal from many sunscreens. Due to public outcry brands begin to remove PABA from their lotion, however, it isn’t until 2019 that the FDA bans the use of PABA.
Oxybenzone use in the US reaches one million pounds per year
Use in sunscreen propels the chemical to be added to the US High Production Volume Challenge Program list, meaning it has hit a manufactured amount and importation amount of one million pounds per year. Oxybenzone is clear, odorless, and broad spectrum, making it one of the most attractive active ingredients to consumers. It also has some UVA protection, which is a rarity in US approved sunscreen ingredients.
The start of UVA protection
Avobenzone becomes the first ingredient to target protection against UVA rays. All other ingredients mostly targeted UVB exposure with a few having some UVA protection. Avobenzone is one of only two ingredients to be approved by the FDA after the initial approval of all other UV filters in 1978.
Oxybenzone outed as most toxic sunscreen ingredient
A study finds that oxybenzone is particularly toxic to corals when compared to other sunscreen ingredients. In the study scientists found that when corals were exposed to high doses in a lab setting oxybenzone caused bleaching, DNA damage, abnormal growth, and developmental deformities in baby corals.
Discovery of why oxybenzone causes bleaching
A landmark Nature study shows that anemones change oxybenzone into a toxic chemical in the presence of UV radiation, which causes them to expel their symbiotic zooxanthellae. Since anemones are close relatives of corals it is likely that they both react to oxybenzone in the same way.
National Academies assessment publishes
The National Academies publishes an extensive assessment calling for further research into the effects of sunscreen on the environment. They assert that chemicals like oxybenzone and octinoxate can have ill effects on corals, but only in high concentrations often not experienced in the natural world, even when high numbers of sunscreen-clad tourists visit a popular site.